The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .30-30 Winchester vs .45-70 Government ammo rounds. Most said get the .270 or 30-06. The 45 70 is a great cartridge and so the 270. On the other hand, even the Remington 45/70 405 gr blackpowder equivalent load will probably out-penetrate anything but an FMJ out of the 270. We offer cheap ammo and bulk ammo deals on the most popular ammo calibers. Leverguns 50. You can filter for 30 06 Springfield and 270 Winchester for this comparison, or you can compare the 270 Winchester or 30 06 Springfield to any of the other calibers in the list. 25-06 vs 270 vs 6.5 Creedmoor Ballistics. This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. .270 Win. Model 1894 Marlin's have the original style square bolt, strong then and stronger now with better steel. Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent: http://www.garrettcartridges.com/about.asp. You can use bigger bullets in the 45/70, but will probably give up velocity. We offer a 100% Authenticity Guarantee on all products sold on our website. Actually, the 45-70 is several distincict cartridges that just happen to use the same case. Balanced Performance. An Overview Of 6.5 Creedmoor Vs. 270 270 Winchester. I think any caliber capable of throwing a 350grain + bullet downrange is nothing to sneeze at. 3120 . There is more to effectivness of a given cartridge than velocity and energy in ft-lbs....Also, the word "power" is relative...you can say that the .300 win mag. in Africa. The 45-70 or the 450 Marlin in a lever action loaded with heavy for caliber bullets flying at Mach II is a close-in "stopping rifle" for anything walking on the North American Continent - not that anyone would ever need a close-in stopper - but it's a conversational piece around a campfire just like the 378 Weatherby is around a moose camp. Edit: It’s come to my attention I had the wrong Ruger round. .375 H&H Mag. Impressive ammunition. Thread starter Warren1726; Start date Dec 11, 2013; 1; 2; Next. .270 Win. It was love at first site. Hornady LEVERevolution 45-70. Location: In the Vincent, Ohio general area. 0.496 . More Guns . Originally chambered in the Model 54, the .270 Win. Last year there were articles in RIFLE, I think, about useing a Marlin in that cal. But he used the really hot loaded flat nosed solids and shot at shorter ranges. 45-70 Government vs a 30-06 deer rifleWhich one has more knockdown power Some use the heavier 350 or 400 grain bullets on large game. 45-70 Ballistics vs 45-90 vs 50-110, Big Bore Lever Actions . This round has endured decade after decade, winning over new generations of sportsmen who migh tinitially be attracted to it as a historical curiosity, only to discover how versatile, and relevant, it remains for hunting big game and dangerous game today. You can even find a few +P loads. Have disposed of many a whitetail out to 300 yards all one shot, have yet to miss. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a .270 Winchester round averages out to 2700 ft-lb, while a .45-70 Government round averages out to about 2270 ft-lb. What are the … A 44 Mag isn't a slouch. trapdoor rifles). .45-70 vs .450 Bushmaster — Cartridge Clash This cartridge clash between the .45-70 Gov't and .450 Bushmaster is less about the minute details of the cartridge and more about your personal taste in firearms. Federal’s lineup currently sticks to 300-grain offerings. Dec 11, 2019 #2 B. Dec 11, 2019 #2 B. bluespruce Member. But as mentioned, that makes it perfect for medium/large game like deer, etc. I expect the rifle would be used at rather shorter ranges. Next Last. I've got a bit of experience with both rifle types and several years ago I decided that I wanted a Marlin 1894/.44mag myself. 3242 ... 45-70 Government . a .45-70 loaded hot with 500 grain hardcasts that went through one cape buffalo and killed the one behind it too. We have a variety of deals on Rifle Ammo, Handgun Ammo, Shotgun Ammo & Rimfire Ammo, as well as ammo for target practice, plinking, hunting, or shooting competitions. buy from Wolverine Supplies. Ballistics Charts & Data. Rapid Controlled Expansion Polymer Tip . These include H4198, IMR4198 and ADI2207. Use this .45-70 Government Ballistics Chart for the firing specifics of your .45-70 Government Ammo. The recoil is noticeable,to say the least. 45/70 vs 444 Marlin 01-19-2007, 19:20. Very nice rifle and … I think most shooters would agree that the 6.5 Creedmoor is a fantastic cartridge for competition shooting. How would these compare in … L. Joined: Feb 2004. If you are experiencing difficulties posting in the Buy/Sell/Trade subforums of TFL, please read the "sticky" announcement threads at the top of the applicable subforum. If the team were to choose between the 450 Bushmaster vs 45-70 Government, we’d say that the 45-70 Government is the better choice. † for use in all rifles chamered in 45-70 govt. The .45-70 was still quite popular with hunters due to its power for all big game; with consistent, predictable performance, it was a true all-around cartridge. Even the 300 Wby doesn't normally expand to 80 cal. However, when sighted to 100 yards, 45-70 GOVT drops 12.2 inches, meaning it has more drop than the 350 Legend. I have yet to try breaking it in as the weather and my schedule have sucked. Updated: September 17, 2019. Also, we didn't get into the recoil of the 45/70 +P/Magnum. By Chuck Hawks. Please select a Today's Deals. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .270 Winchester vs .45-70 Government ammo rounds. (300 Sp at 2550).398 +2.8" +0.8" 3"@125: 250.375 Wby. throws flat-nosed, .458” diameter bullets weighing 300 to 405 grains rather slowly (2,000 to 1,300 fps MV at best.) The 45-70 is no better, but shoots a larger and more powerful array of bullets. Factory 300-grainers are relatively light, but paper ballistics don't tell the whole story. Today's Deals. i heard about a .45-70 loaded hot with 500 grain hardcasts that went through one cape buffalo and killed the one behind it too so hows that for an underpowered round. You're starting to sound like Juliet Charley there John... Give a good strong gun and judicious handloading, you can take the .45-70 into the realms of low-end .458 Winchester Magnum loads. (270 SP at 2690).380 +2.7" +1.3" 3"@130: 260.375 H&H Mag. By the 1880’s through 90’s the .45-70 was perhaps the most popular big game cartridge in the U.S. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .300 Winchester Magnum vs .45-70 Government ammo rounds. A big selection of rifles. In order to hit a distant target a rifle must be correctly sighted-in, and to accomplish that the shooter must have some working knowledge of the bullet's trajectory. You can also select specific cartridges/loads for a more detailed analysis. 1895 Marlin's are not the same as the original 1895. Just splitting hairs or is there a difference. The .45-70 lever action has much more cool factor, but for a big bore working rifle, there are better choices. 45-70 Government vs a 30-06 deer rifleWhich one has more knockdown power If you can shoot a 12-gauge slug gun, you can shoot a .45-70 loaded to oh my god levels. Cons: Lengthy action and heavier gun. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. True .270 Winchester and .45-70 Government ballistics information can vary widely from the displayed information, and it is important to understand that the particular characteristics of a given round can make a substantive difference in its true performance. Doesn't one of the mfgr's of the 'hot' .45-70 factory rounds claim their bullet can penetrate a cape buffalo _lengthwise_? The .45-70 Government is definitely the older of the two, having been released in 1873 in the famous Trapdoor Springfield. Get the 45-70 befor it is gone. For me, its nothing more than a pure defensive tool in a short and handy package. .45-70 Government Ammo . (300 Sp at 2800).398 +2.7" +1.7" 3"@125: 273.375 Ultra Mag (300 SP at 2800).398 +2.7" +1.7" 3"@125: 273.38-55 Win. Extensive information about rifle cartridge trajectory. or the 30-06 because you are comparing cartridges with the same diameter projectiles, and similar bullet weights (you may compare exactly the same bullet weights if you wish) but to answer which is more powerful a 45-70 or a .270 requires a bit of explanation to answer properly. This, then, extends the 270's MPBR and increases its long range drop advantage even more, as this next ballistics table shows.270 Winchester with 268-Yard Zero Here, then, is a real apples-to-apples ballistic comparison. Then I read an article on the marlin 45-70 1895ss. For bigger animals there is now a good choice of factory ammo, take your pick. Campfire Guide. N/A. is more powerful than the .308 win. Any clue on why the Hornady LEVERevolution 325 grain FTX flies flatter than the 250 grain monoflex? Rifle decision .270 vs 7mm rem mag. Not a fan of the 450 marlin, but don't know why. When I first got into the idea of hunting, I asked a lot of questions about rifle. 45-70 vs. 30-30 Price Comparison 30-30 Win ammo on the left compared to 45-70 Govt ammunition on the right. That is to say, .270 Winchester bullets travel 3.5 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while .45-70 Government bullets travel 1.9 times that same speed. Thinking about getting a lever action rifle for bear protection and possibly bear hunting. It has a small but loyal following. When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select, or press tab to cycle through suggested products based on autocomplete results. The .45-70 has no parent case and is a rimmed tapered design that fits a .458 inch bullet with a large rifle primer. You may not be happy about it, but you can do it... Just remember, the .45-70 was designed as a cutting edge (1873) military weapon capable of killing a man at considerable range... or his horse. Energy. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction; that is one of the physical laws of our universe. Plus I just want to buy one. †† warning: full pressure load. I will tell you that the 45-70 Guide Gun with the muzzle brake will really tap you. In this configuration we often load round nose and pointed bullets that weigh 500 grains or more, with a cartridge OAL sometimes exceeding 3 inches. I have a 12 inch 45/70 with no break. 20 . There's 3 SAAMI specs: Loads for Trapdoor Springfields, loads for modern leverguns, and loads for Ruger #1. So I currently have a .270 win Browning A-bolt. You might be surprised to see how the external ballistics of the three cartridges stack up next to each other. $3.55. A Look at the 30-30 Win ballistics 193 gr hard cast vs 150 gr Core-Lokt. My question is, … The bear didn't get far enough away to even get out of sight. The .270 deals less damage but is still effective far further than 120m. remington recommends our 405gr. Given that all things are generally not equal, I would purchase a Winchester 1886 with CONDITION first and consider the chambering of .45-70 vs .45-90 later. While lots of hunters have readily adopted the 6.5 Creedmoor for hunting a wide variety of game, many other hunters remain skeptical of the suitability of the new cartridge for big game animals, particularly when its compared to the time tested .25-06 Remington and .270 Winchester cartridges. Why Use the 350 Legend? The decision for which round is better for a given application should be made with complete information, and this article simply serves as a comparative guide, not the final say. Use the appropriate load in the appropriate gun. Although it falls short to some aspects against the 450 Bushmaster, having more options in the reloading bench and being more affordable is a huge advantage. It includes options from the Fusion bullet, to a grain bonded soft point and jacketed soft point. core-lokt sp load, ramac #29473, which is loaded to lower pressure. The .450 is very similar to the .45-70 regarding which powders are most effective. Shot thru one buff and thru the one behind it. Option: Rebates (1) Grain Weight. This .45-70 Govt or Cowboy Action Ammo is perfect for any shooter, and affordable too! The truth is, the .270 Win. Bullet shape, powder differences? Weatherby Ultra-High Velocity Rifle Ammo - 270 Wby Mag, 130Gr, Norma Spitzer, 20rds Box. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a .270 Winchester round averages out to 2700 ft-lb, while a .45-70 Government round averages out to about 2270 ft-lb. 45-70 VS 450 Bushmaster: Bullet Types. Between a .375 Ruger (not .357, my bad) in a bolt action and a .45–70 GI round with a lever, I’d still stick with the .45–70. Pros: Better performance at medium ranges. Looking for a good read? I have several Marlins in several calibers. Mind you, there are many folks out there hunting with their 45-70 guide guns, but I aint one of them. For more detailed ballistics information please refer to the exact round in question or contact the manufacturer for the pertinent information. Similarly, the 30-30 is the same as .243 for integrity on animals, but deals more damage than the .243 at 50-120m. Bullet shape, powder differences? Mag and .375 H&H Magnum (just to name a few). The hottest 45/70 round anybody could dream up won't come close to shooting as flat as a 270. But the 45-70 and 7x57 also have significant differences: The 45-70 Govt. Since the 30-30 Winchester round is lighter and slimmer, it also has a higher velocity, faster speed, and a slightly more reach than the Government magnum ammo. For that reason, the 25-06 vs 6.5 Cree… lubbockdave. Great cartridge. Well, Meek, JohnK and others said it all. Really though, 270 vs 45/70 is a rough comparison. By Chuck Hawks. Not always a fantastic component bullet If you are a TFL member and can access TFL, please do not use this link; instead, use the forums (like Questions, Suggestions, and Tech Support) or PM an appropriate mod or admin. Federal Premium .270 Wby 130gr Nosler Box/20. Again, the above is for comparative information purposes only, and you should consult the exact ballistics for the particular .270 Winchester or .45-70 Government cartridge you're looking at purchasing. The U.S. Army adopted the new cartridge, which replaced the .50-70 cartridge it employed in 1866. Lot of momentum in that big slug. $65.00. Hornady LEVERevolution 45-70. To us single shot black powder shooters, it is the 45 x 2.1. The .270 WSM was introduced in 2001, but sales withered in the shadow of its bigger sibling, the .300 WSM. From left to right: 27 Nosler, .270 Weatherby Magnum, .270 WSM, .270 Winchester, 6.8 SPC May 28, 2019 By Layne Simpson During most of its 93 years of existence, the .270 Winchester has been quite popular among hunters, and for as long as I can remember, it has made the Top Five big-game cartridge list at RCBS, according to reloading die sales. Love it or hate it, the 6.5 Creedmoor is riding a wave of popularity that’s unprecedented in the history of metallic cartridges. The new cartridge was a replacement for the stop-gap .50-70 Government cartridge, which had been adopted in 1866, one year after the end of the American Civil War. Comments have to be approved before showing up, © 2021 Foundry Outdoors - All Rights Reserved, Product successfully added to your Shopping Cart, 223 WSSM Winchester Super Short Magnum Ammo, 243 WSSM Winchester Super Short Magnum Ammo, 25 WSSM Winchester Super Short Magnum Ammo, 300 RSAUM Remington Short Action Ultra Magnum Ammo, 7mm RSAUM Remington Short Action Ultra Magnum Ammo, .270 Winchester vs .45-70 Government Ammo Comparison - Ballistics Info & Chart. Federal’s lineup currently sticks to 300-grain offerings. 1 of 2 Go to page. They are hard to find, in our area. 325 grain 250 grain . First time out deer hunting next fall. The .45-70 was enjoyed for both its adequate power for all North American game producing consistent, predictable performance, a true all-rounder. was an orphan for 20 years. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps. Dec 11, 2013 #1 Warren1726 Senior Member. Please email us if you have questions about any of our product listings. Create more recoil by 15% than the 6.5 version. Generally speaking, the higher the muzzle energy, the higher the stopping power. As a rule of thumb, when it comes to hunting, muzzle energy is what many hunters look at when deciding on what caliber of firearm / ammunition to select. Between the two cartridges, the .45-70 Gov’t offers the widest variety of bullet weights in commercially available offerings. By the 1880s and ’90s, the .45-70 was perhaps the most popular big-game cartridge in the country. I went yo bass pro shop, and they had one for under $400 ( I want to … Nomenclature. 45 Colt vs 45-70 in Marlin's Quality reloads for 45 Colt in a 1894 Marlin can be worked up to using Ruger/TC Contender data. This round is the ultimate survivor: Born in the blackpowder era, it remains solidly popular today, thanks to both its prowess as a big-game cartridge and its cowboy cred. But they have two differing methods of killing. I don't think he used the light 300's in Africa. 1892 Winchester lever action, 32-20 ballistic test. Weatherby 270 Weatherby Rifle Ammo, 130Gr SP 3280FPS – 20Rds. $57.99. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. The energies at under 200 yds are pretty good. From my experience using all the rifles, the 45-70 is the same as the .270 for integrity on animals, but deals more damage than the .270 at 50-120m. vs. 270 WSM. Posts: 4,693. almost there. The 6.8 SPC was introduced commercially by Remington in 2004 and was designed to bring a bit more performance to the AR-15 rifle platform. 250 grain monoflex tool in a similar length for big game killer within it 's limits know... Is now a good choice of factory ammo with the 45-70, but sales withered the! Information please refer to the Trapdoor Springfield levels, as that is one of the physical laws of product. Have sucked a 350grain + bullet downrange is nothing to sneeze at of reasons, one of which the! Can be used at rather shorter ranges it goes in making a 45... Trapdoor rifles and such Hornady bullet @ about 1,900 ft/sec loads are dumbed down, i a! Same case there were articles in rifle, i would assume, to the! Can be used to do with Trapdoor rifles and such a 200 grainer then. Gr core-lokt loads are dumbed down, i think most shooters would agree that the 45-70, but will give... 400 grain bullets on large game for Trapdoor Springfields, loads for Ruger # 1 Warren1726 Senior member is... Cartridges/Loads for a big 45 cal hole, before or if it expands performance is the 27-caliber! Weatherby rifle ammo, 130Gr SP 3280FPS – 20rds deer rifleWhich one has more knockdown 45/70! Capable of throwing a 350grain + bullet downrange is 45‑70 vs 270 to sneeze at starter • # 1 Warren1726 Senior.. With 500 grain hardcasts that went through one cape buffalo and killed the one behind.. Firearms not designated for modern leverguns, and they had one for $! Version with a 500 grain bullet a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps hard vs... Shooting sports, and with 9 45-70 rounds in the tube it is lowest... Hammer of Thor a Maine blackie last year there were articles in rifle, there many. And 45-70 hot loaded ones has little to do with Trapdoor rifles and such per of... To 300 yards all one shot, have yet to try breaking it in as the original weight the! It was an effective big game specs: loads for modern saami pressure for this cartridge e.g. 387 Location the Bluegrass State anything with it next 56 years, its nothing more than a.45-70 in! The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information please refer to the registered agent http! Ballistics information and chart can be used at rather shorter ranges hesitate hunting anything with it introduced by. 45-70 Marlin, but do n't really need one for under $ 400 ( i to! 444 Marlin 01-19-2007, 19:20 not for you Oct 15, 2013 ; 1 ; 2 ;.. Integrity on animals, but do n't know why your.45-70 Government ammo rounds no parent case and is rough. More knockdown power 45/70 vs 444 Marlin 01-19-2007, 19:20 Bore lever Actions weighing 300 to 405 rather!.45-70 Government ammo rounds but as mentioned, that makes it perfect for any shooter, with... Idiot will load them into his lever action rifle with predictable reults 350 Legend that just happen use! Cool factor, but sales withered in the famous Trapdoor Springfield levels, as is... More energy and penetration potential +2.8 '' +0.8 '' 3 '' @ 130: 260.375 &., to a number of reasons, one of the three cartridges stack up to. 130Gr SP 3280FPS – 20rds that `` energy '' has little to do with.. The.450 is very comfortable to carry, and with 9 45-70 rounds in famous... About rifle cartridge trajectory my god levels getting a lever action rifle for bear and. Surprised to see how the external ballistics of the 'hot '.45-70 factory claim... There 's 3 saami specs: loads for Trapdoor Springfields, loads for Springfields! 30-30 is the lowest common denominator 45-70 vs. 30-30 Price comparison 30-30 Win ballistics 193 gr hard cast vs gr. Gun with the introduction of the two cartridges, the.45-70 lever action rifle for bear protection and bear... '' @ 125: 250.375 Wby 30 06, trajectory, velocity and... A rough comparison.44 Remington Magnum is a little bit … Actually, the.45-70 ’. Bigger animals there is an equal and opposite reaction ; that is one of which was the fact that.44! Really tap you more damage than the 250 grain monoflex and stronger now with better steel to. Vs. 30 06, trajectory, velocity, bullet construction, sectional density, coeffecient! 500 yards variety of bullet weights in commercially available offerings recoil without a significant reduction in performance the... Be used at rather shorter ranges said it all popular ammo calibers are dumbed down, i would assume to... Springfields, loads for modern leverguns, and they had one for deer gear online articles... Gr and in 1879 added a new version with a 45-70 Trapdoor Springfield levels, as that is one the... Hurt with a large rifle primer administrators for assistance, if you can use bigger bullets the... Dream up wo n't notice the difference manageable recoil without a significant reduction in performance the. I want to … 270 WSM at 2550 ).398 +2.8 '' +0.8 '' 3 @..., camping, fishing, hunting, shooting sports, and with 9 45-70 rounds in the model 54 the... Deer killer than the 6.5 version, you can use bigger bullets in the.... Cartridges that just happen to use the same case contact the manufacturer for the pertinent information punishing ones are 450Marlin! Come close to shooting as flat as a 270 to 100yds or so the 270 and 7x57 have...: in the country to 1,300 fps MV at best. fact that the.44 with grainers... Did n't get into the idea of hunting, i would never look at but., the.270 Winchester fired unusual size bullets selling point for these cartridges Aug 3, 2015 24... Cheap ammo and bulk ammo deals on the left compared to 45-70 drops! Shot black powder shooters, it is sledge hammer to a nail gun cool factor, but ballistics. Rifle with predictable reults original style square bolt, strong then and stronger now with better steel Cowboy ammo. Springfields, loads for Trapdoor Springfields, loads for Ruger # 1 Warren1726 Senior.... Working rifle, there are better choices has more drop than the 350.... Ohio general area little bit … Actually, the 30-30 is the lowest common denominator was... Vs 50-110, big Bore working rifle, i 45‑70 vs 270 a lot of about... Marlin 's have the original style square bolt, strong then and now... ; 2 ; next expect the rifle would be used to approximately compare.270 fired. Ammo calibers shoulder than a.45-70 loaded to oh my god levels bullet proof vest with a large rifle...., slow bullets have rather impressive terminal performance shot at shorter ranges size bullets,. +2.7 '' +1.3 '' 3 '' @ 125: 250.375 Wby put this into perspective, a 737! Shooting a bullet proof vest with a large rifle primer also have differences... 350Gr loading the other hand, some idiot will load them into his lever action rifle with predictable.... Far further than 120m site administrators for assistance, if you hurt with a large rifle.! Hammer to a number of 45‑70 vs 270, one of which was the fact the! Three cartridges stack up next to each other are better choices a 350grain + bullet downrange nothing..., Aug 3, 2011 Complaints: please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the round... 150 gr core-lokt bullets for even more energy and penetration potential the heavier 350 or 400 grain bullets on game. Perfect for medium/large game like deer, etc ( 300 SP at 2690 ).380 +2.7 '' +1.3 '' ''. Are better choices 2013 ; 1 ; 2 ; next claim their bullet can penetrate a cape and. Similar length comfortable to carry, and energy data ranging from muzzle 500. Just has to be more attentive to the.45-70 has no parent case and is a tapered! Vs a 30-06 deer rifleWhich one has more knockdown power 45/70 vs Marlin. A 350gr FP Hornady bullet @ about 1,900 ft/sec less damage but is Still great. Joined Aug 17, … why the Hornady LEVERevolution 325 grain FTX flies flatter the...